>> Site Map >> Forums >> Site Suggestions

Forum module - topics in forum:

Site Suggestions - Suggestions on what the site needs, or doesn't need!

Poetry Criticism Topic?

It has now come to my attention that some new poets here prefer to remain anonymous and stay their contribution of comments because of the lack of honest critique going on.

I'd like to know what people think about a separate submission topic dedicated to critical analysis of poems, because if this attitude becomes the norm, then our site would cease to function properly.

I've seen it work on other sites, and I know that most people (if not everyone) desires this, so is it a worthwhile proposition?

Thanks for listening.

Re: Poetry Criticism Topic?

*agrees*

Sounds like a good idea.

Re: Poetry Criticism Topic?

I also think it's a great idea.

Re: Poetry Criticism Topic?

I think that whatever the majority wants is what should be done. No matter the outcome, I will not change the way I comment. It seems perfectly simple to me that is you have a criticism, constructive or otherwise it could just as easily be done through PM's, and not cause Mick more work than is necessary.

Find out who wants help like that and interchange ideas there. Share your questions and ideas through personal IM's.

JMO,

Re: Poetry Criticism Topic?

*nods in agreement*

Nice proposal. That would be a good way to let people know it's okay to give constructive criticism to these people.

-emo.